Factors affecting intention to use e-banking in Jordan

Purpose – Despite the wide availability of internet banking, levels of intention to use such facilities remain variable between countries. The purpose of this paper is to focus on e-banking in a country with low intention to use e-banking – Jordan – and to explain the slow uptake. Design/methodology/approach – A quantitative method employing a cross-sectional survey was used as an appropriate way of meeting the research objectives. The survey was distributed to bank customers in Amman, Jordan, collecting a total of 328 completed questionnaires. SPSS and AMOS software were used, and multiple regression and artificial neural networks were applied to determine the relative impact and importance of e-banking predictors. Findings – The statistical techniques revealed that several major factors, including perceived ease of use, perceived usefulness, security and reasonable price, stand out as the barriers to intention to use e-banking services in Jordan. Originality/value – This study theorizes a series of implications on intention to use e-banking. It draws the attention of Jordanian banks to the full functionality of their e-banking systems, emphasizing positive safety features, which could contribute to changing negative customer perceptions. It also contributes to eliciting the theory of customer value among banks by focusing on how they should properly enhance their use of shared value. Moreover, it will present to managers how e-banking predictors can send meaningful and timely information to customers.


Introduction
The pervasiveness of technology defining the twenty-first century is leading banks to adopt a new set of practices. Today, the best banks recognize the need to have more complete and up-to-date services that go beyond traditional offerings. The e-banking concept is based on the development, design, and implementation of financial services that take place on the internet. Simply, e-banking occurs when customers use the internet to access their bank accounts to carry out banking transactions (Sathye, 1999). Thus, offering multichannel banking has become a competitive necessity and a guarantee of the interaction between banks and their customers (Stoica et al., 2015). Both banks and customers can benefit from e-banking services. Banks can create higher banking efficiency by enabling customers to open accounts, make deposits, transfer funds across accounts and make payments entirely online (Takieddine and Sun, 2016). Customers can undertake financial processes such as buying and fund transfer with speed and convenience (Ling et al., 2016). In particular, e-banking services offer benefits to customers because they can perform their transactions and other financial activities from home.
Despite these e-banking services benefits and the huge investments made by banks into implementing internet banking technology, many customers are reluctant to use these adopted a sequential multi-method research design, as recommended by Scott and Walczak (2009), integrating both structural equation modeling (SEM) and ANN analysis. SEM is employed to verify the validity of causal relationships by examining the goodness of fit of the model. The supported relationships and the significant variables from the SEM analysis were then used as the inputs for the neural network structure to determine the relative importance of significant factors (Liébana-Cabanillas et al., 2017). The use of the sequential multi-method predictive-analytic method (Scott and Walczak, 2009;Shmueli and Koppius, 2010) is deemed to be able to provide a richer and more holistic understanding of the phenomenon under study and thus may provide a significant methodological contribution from the statistical point of view (Leong et al., 2015). Although the ANNs and other expert system techniques are used in previously published studies, to our knowledge, this is the first they are used in e-banking literature. Accordingly, the main aim of this study was not only to determine the most significant factors influencing e-banking adoption, but also the relative importance of each factors in terms of significance. This makes a new contribution to the existing literature in that expert system techniques were applied in a new context of information systems (IS) studies.
This study identifies and empirically examines the main factors predicting the behavioral intention and adoption of e-banking on the part of Jordanian customers. Such a study can also make a significant contribution by highlighting the fundamental aspects taken into account by Jordanian banking clients in shaping their decision to adopt or reject e-banking. Thus, bank managers will be provided with indications as to how they should design and promote e-banking as a self-service technology.
The contributions of this study are twofold. First, it expands on those studies that have treated e-banking in Jordan by expanding to some extent the sample size and presenting a different set of variables than suggested by other researchers (e.g. , drawing on an integrated model of the various factors proposed by earlier studies in Jordan. Second, it positions itself in the e-banking literature, offering a new combination of variables to include both variables associated with e-service delivery and customers. In addition, it investigates the factors influencing internet banking adoption in less-developed regions, particularly in parts of Arabic countries. Indeed, there is lack of country-level studies investigating the factors that make a difference in the diffusion of internet banking across different countries. To fill this gap in the internet banking literature, this study examines internet banking diffusion at the country level (Takieddine and Sun, 2016).
The following sections are organized as follows: the second section comprises of a literature review. The third section presents the theoretical model and hypothesis development; the data analysis and discussion are provided in the fourth section; and, finally, the fifth section outlines the main conclusions, the implications of the results, the potential steps for further research and the main limitations.

Literature review
Explaining and predicting customer intentions and the adoption of internet banking have recently been the focus of many scholars worldwide and this issue has seen dramatic growth in the relevant literature related to online banking channels (Lin, 2011;Purwanegara et al., 2014;Zhou, 2012). Over the last several years, numerous theories offering new insights have emerged (Oruç and Tatar, 2017), aiming to explain and predict the relationship between user beliefs, attitudes and behavioural intentions to use the technology. The technology acceptance model (TAM), theory of planned behavior (TPB), innovation diffusion theory and theory of reasoned action are examples of these theories.
The TAM has been proven to be a valid theory that predicts adoption behavior and behavioural intention, with an emphasis on perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use as the most salient drivers of the acceptance of new technology. Thus, this model has become one 88 IJBM 38,1 of the most widely used model due to its simplicity, parsimony and robustness Chaouali et al., 2016;Koo et al., 2015;Mital et al., 2018;Rawashdeh, 2015). It has also been shown to be superior to other prevalent competing models. Although the extensive replication, application and integration of the TAM have enabled many researchers to understand the adoption of technology, the TAM has its limitations (Benbasat and Barki, 2007;Venkatesh et al., 2007) and there is still a need for systematic investigation and theorizing of the salient factors that apply to context-based consumer technology use. Moreover, researchers have found that studies based on this model provide insufficient guidance to e-banking providers in terms of the roles of network influence and securities. Therefore, there is a need to extend the TAM when studying the adoption of e-banking.
Researchers have attempted to extend the TAM by introducing new factors, exploring the underlying belief factors, and introducing antecedent, moderator and mediator variables into the TAM framework (Wixom and Todd, 2005). Several studies have considered usage/adoption as an important variable of study (Koo et al., 2015;Saeed and Abdinnour, 2013). All such studies have focused on adding a few new variables based on context. The problem is that there are so many new variables in different contexts that are added to the original theory and thus the theory is no longer parsimonious, which is also a challenge for theory development. In the literature, various studies related to the adoption of internet banking have been conducted. These studies provide a further understanding of the main factors predicting customer intention and usage of e-banking; however, other important aspects have yet to be explained, including the role of self-efficacy. Table I summarizes the variables used by various researchers, which can influence the intention to use e-banking. The selection was based on a common ground; all of the studies mentioned in the table were undertaken in developing countries, of which Jordan is one. Table I summarizes the previous literature examining the intention to use e-banking. Several issues are clear. First, the intention to use e-banking services is influenced by many factors, which have varying impacts on usage. Second, according to Shmueli and Koppius (2010), to advance current IS studies, there is a need to integrate predictive-analytic methods as a means of generating data predictions, as well as to adopt methods for assessing predictive power. By employing predictive-analytic techniques, researchers will not only create practically useful models, but also create ones that can help alongside explanatory modelling in theory building and theory testing. Third, when deciding the selection of variables which can affect the intention to use e-banking services, two dimensions should be taken into account: the researcher's recognition of the variables, which may affect the intention to use e-banking services, depending on experience in the environment; and the gaps in knowledge not addressed by previous studies. In this context, the literature on e-banking services is very limited in Jordan. Moreover, most of the studies that do exist tend to focus on comparative research between banks in Jordan and banks in developed countries, such as the work of Migdadi (2008), or the impact of e-banking services on the financial performance of individual banks, such as the research of Al-Smadi (2011). Therefore, it is important to investigate those factors that may affect the intention to use e-banking services in Jordan specifically. The next section discusses these factors based on the current literature.
Therefore, to fill this research gap and to provide a solid theoretical basis for examining the adoption of online banking services in Jordan, this study draws on two main schools of thought: TAM  and TPB (Ajzen, 1991). As the TAM and TPB have been used in many studies to explain user perceptions of system use and the probability of adopting an online service (Hsu et al., 2006), they are the most appropriate tools for understanding online banking adoption.

Theoretical model and hypothesis development
Over the past decade, the TAM and TPB have been widely applied to examine e-banking usage and acceptance (Davis, 1993;Hsu, 2004;Hsu et al., 2006). However, neither the TAM nor TPB have been found to provide consistently superior explanations or behavioural predictions (Chen et al., 2007). Recently, a growing body of research has focused on integrating the two models to examine information technology usage and e-service acceptance because they are complementary; the results of such research have shown that the integrated model has better exploratory power than the individual use of the TAM or TPB (Bosnjak et al., 2006;Chen et al., 2007). The strengths of the TPB have been explored to enrich the TAM by adding usage and placing premiums on specific settings and external variables that influence a technology adoption process (Awa et al., 2015).
As the focus of this study is online banking service adoption, which is an instance of the acceptance of innovative technology intertwined with social systems and personal characteristics, the integration of the TAM and TPB for our research framework should be comprehensive in order to examine the consumers' intentions and acceptance concerning online banking. Hence, the suggested model is on lines with previous studies Colombia UTAUT2 model (performance expectancy, effort expectancy, government support and trust (quality of information, perceived security and perceived privacy) Arora and Sandhu (2018) India Functionality, information, effort expectancy, credibility, performance, self-interest, social influence and service content Marafon et al. (2018) Brazil Self-confidence and risk acceptance as a moderators of the relationship between perceived risk and intention to use internet banking Szopiński (2016) Poland Use of the internet, taking advantage of other banking products as well as trust in commercial banks Chaouali et al. (2016) Tunis Roles of counter-conformity motivation, social influence and trust in explaining customers' intention to adopt internet banking services Ayo et al. (2016) Nigeria Perceived e-service quality, competence of e-service support staff, system availability, service portfolio, responsiveness and reliability were found to be most significant in rating e-service quality  Jordan Unified theory of acceptance and use of technology (UTAUT2) along with trust: behavioral intention, performance expectancy, effort expectancy, hedonic motivation, price value and trust Rawashdeh (2015) Jordan Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, perceived web privacy, attitude and behavioral intention Abu-Assi et al. (2014) Jordan Perceived ease of use, usefulness, compatibility, trialability and security Abbad (2013) Jordan (Subjective norms, security and trust) forms: perceived usefulness.
(Internet experience and enjoyment) forms: perceived ease of use Chang and Rizal (2010) Taiwan Perceived ease of use, perceived usefulness, personal involvement Amin (2009) Malaysia Perceived ease of use, perceived usefulness, perceived credibility, perceived enjoyment and social norm Hua (2009) China Perceived ease of use, privacy, security Celik (2008) Turkey Perceived risk, perceived playfulness, perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use Sohail and Shaikh (2008) KSA Efficiency and security, fulfillment and responsiveness Zolait and Sulaiman (2008) Yemen Relative advantage, compatibility and ease of use Lallmahamood (2007) Malaysia Security and privacy Guriting and Ndubisi (2006) Malaysia Perceived ease of use, perceived usefulness, computer self-efficacy, prior computing experience Kassim and Abdullah (2006) Qatar Ease of use, trust, secure and private who stressing the need to adjust and extend acceptability models to suit the relevant technology (Chen, 2016;Dishaw and Strong, 1999;Kim et al., 2010;Lancelot Miltgen et al., 2013;Moták et al., 2017;Venkatesh et al., 2003;Yousafzai et al., 2010). This adjustment and extension is proposed to identify as broadly as possiblebut still on a sound theoretical basisthe factors capable of predicting the acceptability of new technology, in particular an e-banking. Furthermore, Dahlberg et al. (2015) suggested integrating theories other than the TAM to gain a deeper understanding of the factors that affect consumer acceptance. Figure 1 shows a set of factors that affect the intention to use e-banking services. Intention to use can be described as acceptance and continued use of a product (Sathye, 1999). Hence, when considering the process of intention to use related to e-banking, it is necessary to provide sufficient information so that people are aware of the service and to explain the added value of this service.
Factors influencing adoption are a complex set of different aspects including access technology and infrastructure related factors, sector-specific internet banking factors and other socioeconomic factors. Indeed, the analysis by Centeno (2003) conducted in European Union countries shows that development of a service by the banks is not sufficient, on its own, to ensure adoption. Access infrastructure to the service is a prerequisite and access at home may be a relevant factor. Time and trust are needed to convert consumers of banking services to the use of e-delivery channels, including the internet.
Perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness are the main factors which influence the intention to use of e-banking. Davis et al. (1989) argue that perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness are crucial determinants of system use in an organization. Cooper (1997) argues that ease of use is an important factor when adopting e-banking services. E-banking services should be easy to use in order to ensure customer use. One of the reasons for the failure of e-banking in the USA is the difficulty of use regarding the technological innovation of e-banking services (Dover, 1988). If Jordanian customers are not adopting e-banking, it could be because the online banking services are not easy to use. This can be hypothesized as: H1. Ease of use positively affects Jordanian consumers' attitude to use e-banking.
Usefulness refers to the improvement of job performance resulting from the use of a particular system . Literature on e-banking concludes that there is a positive relationship between perceived usefulness and the intention to use of e-banking TAM and security model  (Pikkarainen et al., 2004;Eriksson et al., 2005;Gounaris and Koritos, 2008;Ozdemir et al., 2008). Hence, this study hypothesizes this relationship as follows: H2. Usefulness positively affects Jordanian consumers' attitude to use e-banking.
A feeling of security when performing transactions on the internet is considered a key factor that removes customer concerns regarding online purchases (Salisbury et al., 2001). Customers tend to increase usage of e-service only if they feel that their transactions are safe (Cheng et al., 2006). It is clear that security influences the use of e-banking services, where high security leads to increasing usage of e-banking services. Hence, there is both theoretical and empirical evidence of a significant association between trust and intention to use e-banking. For example, Doney and Cannon (1997) found that consumer trust is related to intention to use the vendor in the future, whereas Gefen (2000) found trust had a significant effect on purchase intentions and suggested that trust in the e-commerce vendor increases the individual's intention to use the vendor's website. Moreover, prior research has also recognized a significant association between trust and PU (Chircu et al., 2000, Gefen et al., 2003Stewart, 2003). In this vein, Daniel (1999) argued that security is one of the most important factors that influences customer acceptance. It can be concluded that e-banking services will not be adopted unless customers regard them as secure. Such arguments can generate the following hypothesis: H3. Security positively affects Jordanian consumers' attitude to use e-banking.
Within the lead user theory, consumer knowledge has often been used to characterize and identify lead user status, mostly measured based on subjective self-assessment (Park et al., 1994). Within IT literature on adoption, this knowledge has been linked to the actual level of digital skills of users (Sadowski, 2017). Howard and Moore (1982) emphasize that consumers have to become aware of the new product before intention to use. Creating awareness among consumers about a service or product is significant for any intention to use to occur (Alnsour, 2013;Alnsour and Al-Hyari, 2011;Sathye, 1999). Hence, if Jordanian consumers are not adopting e-banking, it may be because they are neither aware that such a service is available, nor of the benefits that it provides. This can be hypothesized as: H4. Awareness positively affects Jordanian consumers' attitude to use e-banking.
The fifth factor, which influences consumer intention to use of e-banking services, is the overall price and cost. Cost includes both the normal costs associated with internet use and the cost of bank fees and charges. Ciciretti et al. (2009) emphasize the importance of price and cost factors in the intention to use of e-banking services. Furthermore, price tends to be a primary characteristic in brand switching (Gupta, 1988). Rayport and Sviokla (1994) confirmed the importance of price in terms of electronic distribution of services. This demonstrates that the intention to use of new technology is related to a reasonable price, where lower prices can attract customers to use such a service. Hence, the following hypothesis can be proposed: H5. Perceptions of price or cost positively affect Jordanian consumers' attitude to use e-banking.
Another important factor that affects intention to use of e-banking service is that the existing mode of service delivery achieves the customers' needs sufficiently (Sathye, 1999). For human resources in banks, to change the current ways of operating and adopt a new technology, it should change their ideas in order to be a competitor (Salisbury et al., 2001). For people, they most likely prefer depending on their knowledge and experience in dealing with banks. This requires fulfilling a certain need to change present ways of operating and intention to use 92 IJBM 38,1 new technology. Unless such a need is encountered, consumers may not be changed their current ways in dealing with banks. Hence, the following hypothesis is proposed: H6. Resistance to change positively affects Jordanian consumers' attitude to use e-banking.
The seventh factor that impacts the use of e-banking services is the availability of access, not only to a computer, but also to the internet, which, per se, is a prerequisite for using e-banking. Ho and Wu (2009) stated that the lack of access to either computers or the internet is one of the possible reasons for the slow growth of e-banking. Daniel (1999) found that low usage of electronic banking in the UK and Ireland is related to a lack of customer access to suitable computers. If the internet is easily accessible, customers will complete their financial transactions (The Australian Government the Treasury, 1997). It can be concluded that the failure to adopt e-banking in Jordan is probably related to a lack of access to computers, the internet or both. Hence, the following hypothesis is proposed: H7. Availability of PC/internet positively affects Jordanian consumers' attitude to use e-banking.
Computer self-efficacy is one of the most important factors that contribute to create a positive performance and, in turn, positive outputs for e-banking services. Self-efficacy is comprised of three dimensions: generalizability, magnitude and strength (Bandura, 1997). Generalizability is the extent to which individual beliefs are limited to a specific domain of activity. This suggests that the use of different types of technology requires individuals to have high generalizability. Magnitude refers to the capability of individuals to accomplish difficult tasks; individuals with high capabilities of self-efficacy are expected to need minimum assistance, whilst individuals with low capabilities of self-efficacy are expected to need maximum support (Lussier and Hendon, 2012). Strength refers to the trust of individuals in their ability to use services (Lussier and Hendon, 2012). It will be interesting to observe how self-efficacy influences the intention to use of e-banking services. Compeau and Higgins (1995) argued that computer self-efficacy is associated with the individual's attitude toward the adoption of new technologies. Previous studies (Igbaria et al., 1995;Johnson, 2005;Mcilroy et al., 2007) also emphasized the effect of computer self-efficacy on adopting new innovations. Chang and Tung (2008) also suggested that self-efficacy plays an important role in motivation and behavior intention. If individuals are pessimistic about their ability to use a new system, then it will not have any significant effect on behavior. Thus, computer self-efficacy may influence the relationship between attitude and behavior toward switching (Lee et al., 2011). A high level of self-efficacy may lead to a high use of e-banking services and vice versa; thus, it can underpin the following hypothesis: H8. Level of self-efficacy positively affects Jordanian consumers' attitude to use e-banking.
Finally to hypotheses were developed that link attitude, intention to use and actual use of e-banking: H9. Jordanian consumers' attitude positively affects intention to use e-banking.
H10. Jordanian consumers' intention to use e-banking positively affects actual use of Internet banking.

Research methods
A quantitative methodology employing a cross-sectional survey was used to address the research objectives.

Sample and collection procedures
Initially, a pre-test was carried out in two ways: the first draft was sent to four professors in IT and a marketing service to ascertain the face and content validity of the questionnaire; and a pilot study was conducted with 32 e-banking service users to evaluate the questionnaire in terms of wording, clarity, relevance and time spent on completion. Finally, only respondents who identified themselves as users of e-banking were included for completion of the questionnaire. According to the Central Bank of Jordan (2015), there are 23 banks, most of which are commercial banks. The researchers distributed the questionnaire randomly to customers. Completed questionnaires were collected during July and September 2016. Of the 1,500 questionnaires distributed, only 480 were deemed usable, yielding a response rate of 32 percent. Regarding the characteristics of respondents, the empirical findings indicate clear variation in their characteristics. Table II illustrates that the sample comprised 49 percent male respondents, and around 64 percent were aged between 30 and 50 years old, whereas only 19 percent were under 30, and the rest were older than 50. Around 68 percent held a Bachelor degree and above, 13 percent held a Diploma, and 19 percent held a high secondary school certificate or below. In terms of usage, 65 percent reported using an online service for communication. Finally, 82 percent had experience of using the internet and only 9 percent had low computer skills. The majority of participants (58 percent) worked in the public sector.

Variable measurements
The 38 items employed to measure the independent variable (TAM and TPB dimensions) were adapted from past studies: (1) scales for perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use were based on Cheng et al. (2006); (2) scales for perceived web security were based on Salisbury et al. (2001); (3) scales for awareness of e-banking services, reasonable price, resistance to change and availability of PC/internet were adopted from AL-Majali and Mat (2011), Abu-shanab et al. (2010), Sathye (1999) and Davis (1989); and (4) value-for-money factors were operationalized in accordance with the works by Adapa and Roy (2017) and Thomas and Sullivan (2005), and were measured using an eightitem scale consisting of two sub-dimensions (perceived benefits and perceived costs). Two dependent variables, namely, intention to use ( four items) and actual usage (three items), were adapted from past studies. A seven-point Likert-type scale was employed to measure the level of agreement for every item, anchored at strongly disagree (1) and strongly agree (7).

SEM-ANN approach
To analyze the data fully and provide bank managers with useful information, this study integrated both SEM and ANN techniques. This integration aimed to overcome the shortcomings of the two techniques implemented individually (Hew et al., 2016). The covariancebased SEM is capable of detecting linear relationships, which leads to the possibilities of oversimplification of the complexities of the decision to adopt e-banking. ANN is able to detect both linear and non-linear relationships, but is not suitable for theory testing, as it is a "blackbox" operation. Hence, ANN as a non-compensatory analysis is able to complement the weaknesses of the compensatory and linear SEM analysis. In addition, ANN is able to "learn" through training processes and tolerate noisy samples; it is thus superior to the partial least square (PLS) method. SEM-ANN analysis provides a more holistic understanding and thus provides significant methodological contributions from the statistical point of view. However, ANN cannot be used alone as it is not suitable for hypothesis testing and does not have the capability of producing path coefficients and p-values, unlike the SEM approach. Therefore, to take advantages of both the SEM and ANN techniques, we engaged an integrated approach by first validating the proposed model followed by the examination of the normalized importance of the significant determinants derived from the SEM analysis. In general, most previous studies have employed only SEM or PLS techniques to verify hypothesized causal relationships and have rarely combined these techniques with other expert systems or artificial intelligence techniques (Chong, 2013;Leong et al., 2015;Wong et al., 2011). Therefore, the outcomes from this study may provide a better theoretical foundation and understanding of the determinants of use behavior from the viewpoint of customers.
To test the proposed model and the suggested causal relationship between the constructs, SEM with maximum likelihood estimation was computed and analyzed in AMOS 21. Following the recommendations of Hair et al. (2010), Leong et al. (2013) and Wang et al. (2014), a two-stage procedure was applied in the measurement model and the structural model. In the first stage, exploratory factor analysis (EFA) was used to identify the underlying constructs involved, followed by a second stage of confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) to ascertain the causal relationships between these constructs via path analysis (Kaplanidou and Vogt, 2006;Liu et al., 2014;Leong et al., 2015;Zopiatis et al., 2014).

Testing the assumptions of multivariate analysis
Before analyzing the data collected, several tests were undertaken for multivariate assumptions, namely normality, multicollinearity and linearity. Construct reliability, validity, and convergent and discriminate validity were also tested.
The descriptive statistics suggest that non-normality was not excessive. Table III illustrates the results of the normality testing in terms of standard deviation, skewness and kurtosis. The maximum absolute values of skewness and kurtosis are 0.73 (o ± 1) and 1.00 (o ± 2) respectively . Furthermore, the histogram, and the normal P-P and Q-Q plots verify the existence of normality, while the scatter plots verify linearity . Common method bias was tested using Harman's one-factor test, loading all indicators of the study constructs into EFA (McFarlin and Sweeney, 1992). The results indicate that common method bias is not a serious concern in this study as the single-factor model exhibited a significantly worse fit. Moreover, the common latent factor in AMOS 25 revealed a shared variance of 13.74 percent, implying the non-existence of common method variance and the Mahalanobis d 2 /independent variables o 3 indicate the non-existence of multivariate outliers (Lee et al., 2011). The multicollinearity of all scale items was tested using the variance inflation factor (VIF) to establish how much of the variance of the estimated coefficient was inflated by multicollinearity (e.g. a VIF of 9 means that the standard error is three times greater than if the VIF is 1). The VIF was 9.79 and the smallest tolerance was 2.29, much less than the common cut-off threshold of 10[1] (Kleinbaum et al., 1988;Teo et al., 2015). Finally, the sample size was 480, which is adequate for SEM (Hair et al., 2010).

Construct validity and reliability
To measure the validity and reliability of the constructs several tests were used. Unidimensionality was measured using a goodness-of-fit index (GFI) for each construct. A value greater than the 0.90 threshold indicates good unidimensionality among the constructs (Prajogo and Hong, 2008). In addition, construct reliability was measured using Cronbach's alpha (α), with a recommended threshold of 0.70 (Nunnally and Bernstein, 1994). Moreover, to establish discriminant validity, the average variance extracted (AVE), maximum-shared squared variance (MSV ) and average shared squared variance (ASV ) were calculated. For discriminant validity, both the MSV and ASV should be less than the AVE (Hair et al., 2010;Fornell and Larcker, 1981). Composite reliability (CR), which uses the actual factor loadings instead of the equal weight for all the constructs, was also calculated. Table IV illustrates the results of these tests. )/(Σ(λi ) 2 +Σδ i )), (λ i ¼ standardized factor loadings, i ¼ observed variables, δ i ¼ error variance); AVE ¼ ((Σ(λi ) 2 )/(n)), (i ¼ 1, …, n, λi ¼ standardized factor loadings, i ¼ observed variables); MSV, maximum-shared squared variance. a These measures were calculated based on Gaskin (2016)  construct loadings significant at p o0.001. This means the all of the constructs in the scale fulfilled the requirements of convergent and discriminant validity; hence, for the measurement model both the reliability and validity of the constructs were successfully verified. Cronbach's α exceeded the value of 0.50.
Measurement model -CFA The next step after testing construct validity and reliability, a measurement model was developed based on the mean values of the indicators for each construct. The fit of the measurement model to the data was assessed using several goodness-of-fit measures, such as normed chi-square ( χ 2 /df ), GFI, the standardized root mean residual (SRMR), the comparative fit index (CFI), the normed fit index (NFI), the incremental fit index (IFI), the Tucker-Lewis index (TLI) and the root mean square error of approximation (RMSEA). Table V illustrates the results of these measures.

Structural model
After establishing an acceptable measurement model, the study evaluated the structural model. Similar to the measurement model, nine GIF measures were used to gauge the fit of the structural model. As reported in Table V, all the measures ( χ 2 /df ¼ 2.75, p ¼ 0.00; GFI ¼ 0.872; CFI ¼ 0.956; NFI ¼ 0.933; IFI ¼ 0.956; TLI ¼ 0.946; RMSEA ¼ 0.061; SRMR ¼ 0.07) exceeded the recommended thresholds. Therefore, the structural model managed to secure a very good fit with the data collected.

Hypothesis testing
To test the proposed hypotheses, path analysis was carried out employing the strength of the regression weights. The significance of a path is determined based on its p-value (Hair et al., 2010). Table VI and Figure 2 present the results of hypothesis testing. Table VI shows the results; the path significance is determined based on the p-value. Furthermore, Figure 2 illustrates the standardized path coefficient (β) with the p-value in parentheses together with the corresponding variance explained by the model (R 2 ). The results imply that 86 percent of the variance (squared multiple correlation) in customers' intention to use internet banking is explained by the relevant dimension, while the actual use of internet banking is able to explain 16 percent of the variance. In addition, Table VI shows, in H1, the relationship between PUSE for ATTD was proposed as positive and the results are admitting the validity of hypothesis. The value of path coefficient β ¼ 0.025 at a significant p o0.01. This implies that the results are strongly supporting the hypothesis. In H2, the relationship between PEOU for was proposed as positive and the results are admitting the validity of hypothesis. The value of path coefficient β ¼ 0.324 at a significant p o0.01. In H3, the relationship between PSEC for ATTD was proposed as positive and the results are admitting the validity of hypothesis. The value of path coefficient β ¼ 0.274 at a significant p o0.01. In H4, the relationship between ATTD for  The value of path coefficient β ¼ 0.324 at a significant p o0.01. In H5, the relationship between SELF for ATTD was proposed as positive and the results are admitting the validity of hypothesis. The value of path coefficient β ¼ 0.32 at a significant po 0.01. In H6, the relationship between RTCH for ATTD was proposed as positive and the results are admitting the validity of hypothesis. The value of path coefficient β ¼ 0.021 at a significant p o0.7. In H7, the relationship between PCAV for ATTD was proposed as positive and the results are admitting the validity of hypothesis. The value of path coefficient β ¼ 0.784 at a significant p o0.01. In H8, the relationship between POPR for ATTD was proposed as positive and the results are admitting the validity of hypothesis. The value of path coefficient β ¼ 0.928 at a significant p o0.01. In H9, the relationship between AWAR for ATTD was proposed as positive and the results are admitting the validity of hypothesis. The value of path coefficient β ¼ 0.001 at a significant p o0.01. In H10, the relationship between AINTN for AUSE was proposed as positive and the results are admitting the validity of hypothesis. The value of path coefficient β ¼ 0.411 at a significant p o0.01. This implies that the results are strongly supporting H1-H5 and H8-H10. However, resistance to technology (H6) and PC availability (H7) did not show significant impact on intention to use internet banking.

ANN analysis
The significant determinants from the SEM analysis were employed as the input variables for the ANN analysis using SPSS 23. A multi-layer perceptron (MLP) with a x 2 x 3 x 4 x 5 x 8  feedforward-back propagation algorithm in which the input signals are fed in a forward direction while the error signals propagate in a backward direction were engaged. Based on the conceptual model presented in Figure 1, two different neural networks are presented. The first neural network captures the effect of the six input variables ease of use (x 1 ), perceived usefulness (x 2 ), perceived security (x 3 ), self-efficacy (x 4 ), awareness (x 5 ) and perceived price (x 8 ), and the output layer, consisting of one parameter, intention to use ( y 1 ).
The second neural network studies the effect of perceived usefulness and intention to use e-banking based on actual use of e-banking. Figure 2 presents a schematic structure of the neural network of perceptron optimization of the ANN obtained by studying the layout of the network and assessing the correlation between the experimental data obtained and the output of the neural network (predicted values). To avoid over-fitting, a tenfold cross validation with a data partition of 90:10 for training and testing was conducted. The number of hidden neurons was generated automatically and the sigmoid function was used for both output and hidden layers . The relevance of the predictor variables was validated based on the number of non-zero synaptic weights connected to the hidden layer. RMSEA was used to assess the accuracy of the ANN model, while the normalized importance of each predictor was calculated in the sensitivity analysis (Table VII). The mean RMSEA values ranged from 0.0755 to 0.0849, indicating high predictive accuracy.
For further analysis, Table VIII illustrates the overall independent importance of the variables in the data. The sensitivity analysis of variable importance of the first neural network shows that perceived usefulness was the most essential determinant of customer intention to use e-banking services, followed by self-efficacy and perceived price.

Factors affecting intention
The second neural network shows that perceived usefulness was the most essential determinant of customers' actual use of e-banking services. This result highlights the importance of perceived usefulness as a main predictor of both intention and actual use of e-banking services.

Discussion
This study integrates SEM with ANN to overcome the shortcomings of both techniques by first validating the proposed model using SEM, followed by examining the normalized importance of the significant determinants derived from the SEM analysis. The descriptive statistics reveal that all respondents have heard of e-banking services but only 54 percent of them use such services. This demonstrates that marketing instruments for e-banking services within banks have not played a successful role in providing full awareness or the benefits of e-banking services to clients. It would seem that the problem of non-intention to use e-banking services is strongly related to the promotion of e-banking services by the banks.
The results imply that the relevant dimension explains 86 percent of the variance in customers' intention to use internet banking, while the actual use of internet banking is able to explain 16 percent of the variance. As Table VI shows, the findings reveal that ease of use, perceived usefulness, perceived security, self-efficacy, awareness and perceived price have significant and positive impacts on intention to use internet banking, supporting H1-H5 and H8-H10, whereas resistance to technology and PC availability (H6 and H7) show no significant impact on intention to use internet banking.
Perceived ease of use has a significant impact on the intention to use e-banking services and this plays an important role in intention to use on the part of customers. This result implies that banks need to make e-banking services easier to use. The research results reveal that issues with ease of use have a significant impact on the intention to use e-banking services; problems stem from the lack of smoothing instruments in banks to enable clients to feel comfortable with their use and adopt e-banking services. Complicated electronic procedures and the excessive time taken to execute financial processes are indicative of challenges in the use of e-banking services. The impact of perceived ease of use on the intention to use e-banking services has been put forward by numerous researchers (AL-Majali and Mat, 2011;Cheng et al., 2006). In addition, this result is in line with those of Rawashdeh (2015) and, to some extent, with Rodrigues et al. (2017), which show that perceived ease of use, perceived usefulness, subjective norms, security and trust, internet experience and enjoyment are important factors that affect customers' adoption of e-banking in Jordan. However, this result is inconsistent with that of Adapa and Roy (2017), who show that technological factors, channel factors and value-for-money factors partially influence consumers' post-adoption behavior with regard to internet banking. Table VI confirms that perceived usefulness has a significant positive impact on intention to use e-banking services. This finding suggests that the degree to which a respondent believes the use of e-banking services would improve his/her (job) performance is low. This result is consistent with the current literature (AL-Majali and Mat, 2011;Cheng et al., 2006;Yiu et al., 2007). Also, it reveals that internet security has a significant impact on the intention to use e-banking services. A high value for the standardized coefficient (β ¼ 0.415) compared to other variables suggests its strong effect on the intention to use e-banking services. This result suggests that Jordanian customers are concerned about the safety of e-banking services. It appears that people do not trust the internet as a whole, which, in turn, provides a reason for non-intention to use e-banking services. Presumably, through observations, Jordanian people do not know who might be looking at their transactions. This behavior might be influenced by political tensions in the region and the censorship by government on the internet (see Warf, 2012). Security is a key factor because 100 IJBM 38,1 it is influenced by other social-economic variables. For example, one instance of adverse media publicity can harm consumer trust in e-banking. An effective response to such publicity can assist in allaying customer concerns and restore their trust. Some banks provide such updates to their customers; however, others do not. This suggests there is a general need for banks to redevelop their strategies for presenting security information in a manner that is easy to understand, in order to enhance the perception of e-banking as a safe process for conduct banking business. Empirical findings (Guerrero, 2007) support this.
The findings also reveal that a reasonable price has a significant impact on the intention to use e-banking services. The price/cost of the internet use in Jordan is relatively high due to taxes imposed by the government on communication companies, while the average income level is low. The lack of disposable income has made it difficult for the public to keep up with the rising cost of internet use. This result demonstrates that the price of the internet is not coherent with people's income, which then affects the cost of the use of e-banking services and intention to use such services. Banks could reduce operating costs for their customers, providing a low-cost service. According to Table VI, resistance to change has no significant impact on the intention to use e-banking services.
The ANN results show that the mean RMSEA values range from 0.0755 to 0.0849, indicating high predictive accuracy. The overall importance of the independent variable of the first neural network shows that perceived usefulness is the most essential determinant of customer intention to use e-banking services, followed by self-efficacy and perceived price. The second neural network shows that the perceived usefulness is the most essential determinant of customers' actual use of e-banking services, highlighting the importance of perceived usefulness as a main predictor of both intention and actual use.

Conclusion and recommendations
In this study, factors that contribute to enhancing the intention to use e-banking are presented in the context of the banking sector in Jordan by integrating the TAM and TPB models. The conjoined SEM-ANN analysis provides a more holistic understanding and thus may provide significant methodological contributions from the statistical point of view. Such research will help banks to formulate marketing strategies, which will lead to the creation of suitable products that attract customers to use e-banking and thus reduce their operating costs.
This study could be helpful to bankers in explaining the currently relatively low penetration rate of e-banking in formulating strategies to encourage the adoption and acceptance of e-banking by Jordanian customers, a country in which e-banking is still considered an innovation. It also contributes to the literature on technology adoption and acceptance, which many researchers have recommended be expanded to new contexts, specifically in terms of the generalizability and applicability of the TAM in a new context (online banking), with a new user group (consumers) and in new cultural setting ( Jordan), a critical step in advancing a theory. The findings of this study provide support for the current literature on e-banking services. The results support the view that the intention to use e-banking services is influenced by several major factors, including perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, security and reasonable price. However, these factors are notable as barriers to intention to use e-banking services in Jordan.

Managerial implications
Out of the eight dependent factors that introduced into the model, only the sub-dimension of relative advantage shows a significant relationship with consumers' continued use of e-banking behavior. This finding is particularly important for bank managers in formulating effective strategies for service delivery channel to retain and expand their existing customer base (Adapa and Roy, 2017). Bank managers need to focus more on using marketing communications in order to widely publicize the advantages associated with the use of e-banking. Bankers can use advertising to influence consumers' attitudes toward the e-bank services, which, in turn, affect the intention to use e-banking (Page and Luding, 2003;Laskey et al., 1992). Word-of-mouth (WOM) is another way to influence consumers' attitudes that can take place in a telephone conversation or within the context of a chat group on the internet (Kasper Helsdingen and Vries, 1999). Thus, both advertising and WOM process are offer special solutions to the problem of intangibility of services and they might help to overcome a service's problem of credibility (Bayus, 1985). Furthermore, personal selling is other way to increase the awareness between customers and influence their attitudes (Burnett and Moriarty, 1998;Kasper et al., 1999).
Furthermore, bank managers need to improve the security features of their systems to assure their customers that e-banking services are safe. Emphasizing positive safety features could contribute to changing negative customer perceptions. Hence, banks should disseminate an effective message to users that current security is more than adequate, thereby enabling users to feel secure when using e-banking services. Bank managers should also enhance their use of shared value by collecting data regarding preferences and feedback from customers. This could be implemented through online surveys and/or a discussion forum. Such actions could improve the intention to use e-banking services.
Additional research could be conducted, as this study does not cover all the variables that affect intention to use e-banking services. Further research could focus on other variables, such as bank management, image or quality of online services. Moreover, examining other theories would greatly support decision makers and researchers in Jordan. Conducting comparative research in other countries with similar conditions would also extensively enrich and enhance current knowledge.

Summary statement of contribution
This study adopted a sequential predictive-analytic method by integrating both SEM and ANN. This helps in providing a more holistic understanding of the phenomenon under study and provides a significant methodological contribution from a statistical point of view.
It also makes significant practical contributions by highlighting the fundamental aspects taken into account by clients in shaping their decision to adopt e-banking, which helps in creating suitable products that attract them to use e-banking.