Commonly used clinical criteria following ACL reconstruction including time from surgery and isokinetic limb symmetry thresholds are not associated with between-limb loading deficits during running

Abstract

ObjectivesWe included objective measures of gait and functional assessments to examine their associations in athletes who had recently commenced running after ACL reconstruction. DesignCross-sectional. SettingSports medicine. Participants65 male athletes with a history of ACL reconstruction. Main outcome measuresTime from surgery, isokinetic knee extension/flexion strength (60°/s), and peak vertical ground reaction force (pVGRF) measured during running using an instrumented treadmill. We also investigated if a range of recommended isokinetic thresholds (e.g. > 70% quadriceps limb symmetry index) affected the magnitude of pVGRF asymmetry during running. ResultsThere were significant relationships between quadriceps (r = 0.50) and hamstrings (r = 0.46) peak torque and pVGRF. Quadriceps peak torque explained a quarter of the variance in pVGRF (R2 = 0.24; p < 0.001). There was no association was between running pVGRF and time from surgery. Between-group differences in running pVGRF LSI% were trivial (d < 0.20) for all quadriceps and hamstring peak torque LSI thresholds. ConclusionsCurrent clinical criteria including time from surgery and isokinetic strength limb symmetry thresholds were not associated with lower pVGRF asymmetry measured during running. Quadriceps strength is important, but ‘minimum symmetry thresholds’ should be used with caution.